Greenpeace - No Excuses

2.2.2 Supermarkets Do Have a Choice : Secondary Cooling Systems

But supermarkets do have a choice. There are alternative refrigeration systems available which are environmentally much more responsible, technically proven, and commercially available.

Numerous environmentally concerned supermarkets throughout Europe have already installed HCFC and HFC-free 'Greenfreeze' technologies, using secondary cooling systems for both chilling and freezing capacity. In some locations, although HFCs have not been completely eliminated, the volume of HFCs used has been significantly reduced with the installation of a secondary cooling system.

Secondary cooling systems use coolants such as water, brine, glycols, silicon oils, or binary ice to circulate through the refrigeration cabinets. The coolant itself is chilled, through a heat exchanger by a primary refrigeration circuit using ammonia or hydrocarbons.

This means that there is no longer the need to circulate a primary coolant, such as CFCs or HCFCs throughout the store and the volume of primary coolant needed is significantly reduced. The primary circuit is usually located in a safely isolated plant room in the back of the store.

The ideal secondary coolant will have: (a) constant temperature to give even cooling in a long circuit; (b) good heat transfer properties for energy efficiency; (c) high energy density to reduce coolant volume; (d) low cost and easy maintenance; (e) no adverse environmental impacts.

A new product, marketed under the trademark Flo-Ice by Integral Technologie GmbH of Germany , reportedly meets these requirements by using a suspension of small ice-crystals in a water/ethanol mixture as the secondary coolant. Integral has Flo-Ice technology partners in Germany, Holland, Luxembourg, France, Norway and Switzerland.

The Danish company Danfoss and the Danish Technological Institute are both actively engaged in the development of secondary refrigerants and indirect refrigeration systems.

There is a rapidly growing list of environmentally conscious supermarkets in Europe that have already installed or are in the process of installing secondary cooling refrigeration. These include Migros Stores (Switzerland); Sainsburys , Marks & Spencers (UK); Match, Cactus, Knauf (Luxembourg); Obs! (Norway); Grosso, Edeka (Germany); ADEG, KGM, (Austria); Albert Heijn Store (Holland).

Suppliers of secondary cooling equipment are widespread in Europe and North America.

The decision supermarkets now face will have long term implications for their shareholders, customers, the environment and future generations. It is in the financial interest of shareholders that supermarkets invest in technologies that are environmentally sustainable. HCFC and HFC technologies are harmful to the environment. They are therefore obsolete and a bad investment. Environmentally alert customers will want to be assured that their favourite supermarkets use environmentally responsible technologies. Investing in environmentally safer secondary cooling systems therefore makes good business sense.


Go Back Index: No Excuses Go Forward



* Danish Environmental Protection Agency, "Polyurethane Foam Without Ozone Depleting Substances": Environmental project # 300, 1995 [return]