Nuclear Home PageNuclear Press ReleasesPress Release Finder

GREENPEACE DIRECTORS APPEAL TO CLINTON TO POSTPONE CASSINI SPACE LAUNCH - URGE USE OF SOLAR TECHNOLOGY

Washington, USA 10 October 1997

The Directors of Greenpeace International and Greenpeace USA have appealed to President Clinton to postpone the launch of the Cassini space probe to Saturn until NASA can implement a solar-powered alternative. Greenpeace considers the Cassini probe a grave threat to global health and the environment.

Cassini, scheduled to be launched by NASA on Monday, October 13, carries 72 pounds of plutonium in devices that generate electricity. Dispersal of the plutonium in the event of a launch pad accident or disintegration in the atmosphere could pose a grave health risk. Minute particles of plutonium are carcinogenic if inhaled and atmospheric disintegration could lead to exposure of this deadly material to the global population.

In the letter sent on October 8, Thilo Bode, Greenpeace International Executive Director and Kristen Engberg, Acting Executive Director of Greenpeace USA, appealed to Clinton to display global leadership by reconsidering the impact of plutonium dispersal beyond the US borders. The two directors further urged Clinton to direct NASA to develop solar-powered cells to replace the Radioisotope Thermoelectric Generators (RTGs), which produce electricity based on the decay heat of the nuclear substance.

"A plutonium-fueled spacecraft not only creates a potential global hazard, but also sends the wrong signal regarding our energy and resource future," said the letter to President Clinton.

The European Space Agency (ESA), which produced the probe, stated in an 29-April-1994, news release that it "has recently developed high efficiency solar cells for use in future demanding deep-space missions." Further technological breakthroughs by the ESA, in the field of high efficiency solar cells, are expected in the next few years. In spite of the pending availability of this alternative technology, NASA has chosen to continue using the dangerous plutonium-based energy source. The ESA stated in the news release that, "Until now, deep space probes had to use thermonuclear power generators, like the so called RTGs (Radioisotope Thermal Generators).

As RTG's technology is not available in Europe, ESA therefore attempted to develop a power source based on very high-efficiency solar cells." It is hoped such solar cells will also have terrestrial applications. Solar power is considered an essential energy source for the next century, with current solar technology already in use around the world.

RTGs are produced at the Department of Energy's nuclear weapons facility at the Los Alamos National Laboratory, NM. Plutonium-238 in the past was produced in military reactor at DOE's Savannah River Plant, SC, by bombarding neptunium targets with neutrons in the reactor. Separation of plutonium-238 via reprocessing produces a large volume of dangerous high-level nuclear waste; waste which will present an environmental threat for thousands of years.

Greenpeace will oppose future use of plutonium on space launches and will continue to appeal for a halt to the use of this dangerous substance. Likewise, the organization will continue its active campaigning to halt the reprocessing and stockpiling of weapon-usable plutonium (plutonium-239) in France, Britain, Russia, Japan, and other countries.

For further information please contact:

Tom Clements, Greenpeace International Nuclear Campaign, + 1-202-319-2506

Andrew Davies, Greenpeace USA Media Department, + 1-202-319-2432


Note to editors:

European Space Agency news release is available on request


8-October-1997

President William J. Clinton
President of the United States of America
The White House
1600 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW
Washington, DC 20500

Via U.S. Mail and Facsimile (202-456-2883)

Re: Taking NASA Into the Solar Age

Dear President Clinton:

We are writing to express dismay and steadfast opposition to the planned launch of 72 pounds of plutonium into space onboard the Cassini space probe. This action contradicts your expressed concern for the environment, health and human rights. We appeal to you to postpone the launch while NASA develops a solar-powered alternative.

It is particularly important at this moment in history that your administration visibly promotes clean energy alternatives, in this case solar power, and rejects dangerous nuclear technology. Any action by the U.S. space program is highly visible and symbolic and inevitably has far-reaching impacts. A plutonium- fueled spacecraft not only creates a potential global hazard but also sends the wrong signal regarding our energy and resource future.

Even if the U.S. government gains the understanding of the American public that the benefits of plutonium in space outweigh the risks -- a consensus that judging from the news of protests is clearly absent -- legitimate concerns arise from those outside the United States. The well-being of the global environment and human populations around the world, which are not represented in the U.S. political system, are also at risk. It is simply wrong for a single nation to place others in the path of such a threat.

Even though the launch of Cassini is now scheduled for October 13, 1997, it is not too late for you to make the right decision. You still have the opportunity to demonstrate that you put the well-being of the global environment and people worldwide before the narrow interests of NASA. We encourage you to demonstrate such global leadership by halting the launch. Moreover, a postponement while a solar alternative is developed could actually benefit NASA in the future. The European Space Agency has recently developed high-performance solar cells that an official at the agency says will soon be perfected to enable them to power deep space missions.

We encourage you to direct NASA to vigorously pursue this new solar technology. As we explore the heavens for information about distant planets -- which Greenpeace certainly does not oppose -- let us not neglect to protect present and future generations on our own planet.

Sincerely,

Kristen Engberg
Executive Director (Acting)
Greenpeace USA

Thilo Bode
Executive Director
Greenpeace International

Back to press release